The Schleswig-Holstein query was a Nineteenth-century diplomatic puzzle supposedly understood by solely three individuals. They variously died, went mad or forgot the small print, stated the British statesman Lord Palmerston. Now the north German state is on the coronary heart of a totally fashionable conundrum.
How ought to Germany transport renewable vitality from locations the place it’s plentiful, together with windswept Schleswig-Holstein, to locations it’s wanted however the grid can not serve? To some buyers and policymakers the reply is easy: hydrogen.
That definitely is smart to HH2E, a renewable vitality venture developer. It hopes to dot northern Germany with electrolysis crops turning electrical energy from wind farms into the fuel, hoping to earn inner charges of return “in the low to mid-teens”.
HH2E simply raised €12mn in fairness from buyers together with HydrogenOne, a enterprise backed by British chemical substances tycoon Jim Ratcliffe. The companions have conditionally agreed to contribute to hydrogen initiatives costing greater than €500mn throughout Germany.
HH2E initially plans to supply inexperienced hydrogen at instances of the day when renewable electrical energy is affordable to gasoline automobiles and chemical crops. Hydrogen evokes explicit enthusiasm in Germany as a low-carbon gasoline for trade. Germany is an environmentally aware nation whose three-party coalition authorities consists of the Greens. It can also be Europe’s industrial powerhouse and its largest emitter of carbon dioxide.
Coal-fired energy stations are largely guilty, an issue the push to scale back Russian hydrocarbons imports is doing nothing to alleviate. The metal trade is one other perpetrator. The bulk of Germany’s 40mn tonnes of annual metal output final 12 months was made utilizing coking coal, producing round a tenth of all carbon emissions.
Earlier this 12 months, steelmaker Salzgitter pledged to modify over to smelters powered by hydrogen and electrical energy by 2033. Larger rival ThyssenKrupp has promised to chop steelmaking emissions by a 3rd by 2030. It is, in the meantime, planning to listing Nucera, a subsidiary that makes hydrogen gear for refining, which has a mooted valuation of as much as €6bn.
Politicians are enthusiastic proponents of hydrogen too. A few weeks in the past, the European Commission set a goal for the EU to supply 10mn tonnes of home inexperienced hydrogen a 12 months by 2030, importing the identical quantity. German legislators aspire to put in hydrogen crops requiring 10 gigawatts of renewable electrical energy capability by the identical deadline.
We must be glad for hydrogen, an industrial fuel which, it if have been the writer of confessional literature, would admit to having “been in a dark place”. In the Thirties, a promising function within the airship enterprise ended explosively. And till a couple of years in the past, anybody who instructed hydrogen could be helpful within the round financial system risked being pigeonholed as a crank.
So much is now being anticipated of hydrogen — and of the non-public sector buyers who can be wanted to fund new manufacturing capability. Switching the German metal trade from coking coal to hydrogen can be an enormous endeavour, for instance. Some back-of-an-envelope figures underline this.
German steelmakers require about 180 terawatt hours of vitality a 12 months, I calculate, equal to five.4mn tonnes of hydrogen. But changing electrical energy into the fuel is inefficient. So electrolysis crops would suck up some 270 terawatt hours of juice. That can be just below half Germany’s projected manufacturing of renewable vitality.
The value can be steep. Hydrogen costs are exhausting to forecast within the present nascent market. Rafi Ghazi, head of company finance at HH2E, says motorists at present pay round €9 per kg. Wholesale costs are anticipated to settle at a decrease stage as manufacturing will increase, at €3-€4 per kg. Coking coal yields the identical vitality at far decrease monetary expense however at a a lot heftier value in carbon emissions.
You may rapidly drive your self as mad as an knowledgeable within the Schleswig-Holstein query by flexing statistical assumptions. The backside line is that weaning German furnaces off coking coal can be costly.
To lure the tens of billions of euros in funding for hydrogen manufacturing, the German authorities should do two issues. First, write an in depth transition plan, so buyers know what to anticipate. Second, cowl the value hole with fuels like coking coal. The value can be borne, a technique or one other, by taxpayers.
Hardly a well-liked message when residing prices are hovering. But is there ever a superb time to inform somebody unhealthy information?
The colors of the hydrogen rainbow
Green hydrogen Made by utilizing clear electrical energy from renewable vitality to electrolyse water (H2O), separating the hydrogen atom from its molecular twin oxygen. Currently costly.
Blue hydrogen Produced utilizing fuel however with carbon emissions being captured and saved, or reused. Negligible quantities in manufacturing resulting from an absence of seize initiatives.
Grey hydrogen This is the commonest type of hydrogen manufacturing. It comes from pure fuel by way of steam methane reformation however with out emissions seize.
Brown hydrogen The most cost-effective method to make hydrogen but additionally probably the most environmentally damaging resulting from using thermal coal within the manufacturing course of.
Turquoise hydrogen Uses a course of known as methane pyrolysis to supply hydrogen and strong carbon. Not confirmed at scale. Concerns round methane leakage.
Where local weather change meets enterprise, markets and politics. Explore the FT’s protection right here.
Are you interested by the FT’s environmental sustainability commitments? Find out extra about our science-based targets right here